Judges Reject Apple Bid to Appeal VirnetX Patent Case

Legal cost patent law dollars money hutterstock

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit rejected Apple's bid to appeal a patent infringement case with VirnetX on Monday (via Reuters). The full court on Monday refused to reconsider the November ruling.

Then in April 2018, a federal court in Texas ordered Apple to pay $502.6 million to VirnetX for violating four patents relating to internet-based communications, which mostly means the underlying technology behind Apple products like FaceTime and iMessage. Over the past three months, VirnetX's stock has dropped 19%, while Apple shares have run up 23% and the Dow Jones Industrial Average has gained 5.9%.Market Pulse Stories are Rapid-fire, short news bursts on stocks and markets as they move. An appeals court whittled the infringing patents to just two.

VirnetX rose 10% to $4.66 at 2:38 p.m.in NY trading, after jumping as much as 18% earlier Monday.

The patent dispute between VirnetX and Apple dates back to 2010 when VirnetX accused Apple's FaceTime function of infringing its intellectual property, and there are multiple lawsuits involved.


The Texas judge in the case must reportedly decide whether to hold a new damages-only trial or to recalculate damages without holding one.

Apple contested the court's findings, and sought a mistrial and a termination to any royalty obligations. Apple is asking the Supreme Court to consider the case, particularly how damages are calculated. Apple contends that it shouldn't be forced to pay royalties on patents that shouldn't have been issued. VirnetX has said that there is no final decision to cancel those patents, so Apple's argument is premature and part of an ongoing effort to avoid paying for the use of another company's inventions.

"We are extremely pleased with the Federal Court's decision to deny Apple's requests for an en banc and panel rehearing", said VirnetX Chief Executive Kendall Larsen.

Related:

Comments

Latest news

Two more arrested over UK truck deaths
Police believe that trucks were used to illegally introduce people to the United Kingdom through the port. Specialists from the National Crime Agency and Vietnamese officers will be joining them for their visits.

Why Kourtney Kardashian Is 'Happy' To Be Filming Less Of 'KUWTK'
The Keeping Up With The Kardashians , 22, looked sensational in a sizzling red ensemble which showed off every inch of her frame. We bring you the latest celebrity news about Justin Bieber, Kylie Jenner , Selena Gomez, Kardashians, and much more, every day.

Keaton Jennings’ skill against spin key to call-up for Sri Lanka tour
Jennings played the last of his 17 tests on the West Indies tour last February, struggling to settle in global cricket, averaging 25.19.

Pope Francis rules out ordaining married men as priests
At the Vatican's press conference, however, Czerny and others denied that the final document has magisterial authority. Francis didn't even refer to the recommendations by Amazonian bishops to consider the ordination of married deacons.

The World Health Organization Named The New Coronavirus "COVID-19"
A total of 48,206 cases of COVID-19 are now being treated in Hubei province alone, a lot of them in the city of Wuhan. Passengers on board the ship have been subjected to regular health checks throughout the troubled journey.

Other news