Seeing red? Louboutin faces setback in Dutch trade mark court battle

A Christian Louboutin autographed shoe in Seattle

But an advocate general at the European Court of Justice advised the court that Louboutin's trademark protection on the shade of red used on his soles, dating from 2010 and 2013, might be invalid.

Louboutin started the legal action in 2012, when Van Haren brought out a range of shoes by actress Halle Berry which included high heeled shoes with red soles.

"Whilst relevant consumers may instantly recognise a red sole shoe being uniquely associated with Louboutin, trying to persuade the courts to grant monopoly rights with such a "badge of origin" may well be an insurmountable hurdle", said Sanjay Kapur, partner at intellectual property firm Potter Clarkson LLP.

French luxury shoe brand Louboutin, typified by its red soled footwear, has had a major setback in its lawsuit against Dutch shoe retailer Van Haren.


The classic red sole of a Christian Louboutin shoe was apparently invented when he painted his assistant's nail varnish on the sole.

The Court's advocate general, Maciej Szpunar, yesterday said that the color red could not be considered apart from the shape of the sole, with shapes not usually protected under European Union trade mark law.

Elaine O'Hare, senior associate at United Kingdom law firm Stevens & Bolton, told World Intellectual Property Review: "The brand will be seriously restricted in being able to protect the red sole as a "badge of origin", and there is a danger that the once-exclusive red soles will no longer be limited to Louboutin shoes". Such an opinion is likely to be highly influential on judges' decision, which has yet to be made.

Focusing his attention on the fact that Louboutin's mark combines color and shape, however, Szpunar said "the concept of a shape which "gives substantial value" to the goods, within the meaning of that provision, relates only to the intrinsic value of the shape, and does not permit the reputation of the mark or its proprietor to be taken into account".

Related:

Comments

Latest news

Toad isn't wearing a hat, Nintendo confirms
Super Mario Bros .is one of those pop culture phenomenons that the majority of people a certain age will always love revisiting. Dorkly raised the question, presented some convincing evidence , and Team Head and Team Hat have been going at it since.

Abu Dhabi set to introduce road tolls
The maximum fine for any one vehicle within the first year of committing the offence is Dhs25,000 ($6,807). Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation; H.H.

$0.71 EPS Expected for ARRIS International plc (ARRS)
In related news, SVP Philip Charles Baldock sold 4,930 shares of the stock in a transaction dated Thursday, January 4th. TheStreet upgraded ARRIS International from a c+ rating to a b rating in a research report on Monday, October 9th.

Cesc Fabregas: 'Eden Hazard can win Ballon d'Or'
As per Sky Sports , Hazard was included in Fabregas' five-aside-team that consists of his teammates from the past and present. Eden Hazard has all the attributes to win the Ballon d'Or, according to Chelsea team-mate Cesc Fabregas .

Home Intelligence Will Doubtless Launch Dem's Counter-memo
The confirmation about Papadopoulos is "the most important fact disclosed in this otherwise shoddy memo", Schiff said Saturday. But Democratic and Republican lawmakers say that assertion is wrong. "Must be stopped!" Trump wrote in a post on Twitter.

Other news