Judges reveal the true voter fraud in North Carolina

Illustration of the State of North Carolina silhouette map and flag. Its a JPG image

Robert Rucho and Rep. David Lewis, co-chairs of the Joint Select Committee on Congressional Redistricting; Timothy K. Moore, speaker of the North Carolina House of Representatives; and Philip E. Berger, president pro tempore of the North Carolina Senate.

The congressional boundaries in question were drawn by the Republican-controlled legislature in 2011 after the 2010 census.

Judge Jim Wynn of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals wrote, "We find that the General Assembly drew and enacted the 2016 plan with intent to subordinate the interests of non-Republican voters and entrench Republican control of North Carolina's congressional delegation".

"And warming the heart of constitutional law professors everywhere, the court twice cited John Hart Ely, the progenitor of the argument that judicial intervention is most necessary (and most appropriate in a democracy) when there has been a malfunction of the political process", he continued.

The request comes less than a day after the state officials filed a notice of their appeal to the Supreme Court. It is one of several cases nationwide involving redistricting.

In an emergency application, the Tar Heel State lawmakers focused on time constraints - as well as "multiple entirely novel theories" the lower court adopted in Tuesday's ruling - that struck down the state's 2016 congressional map as an unconstitutional partisan gerrymander. The judges said Republicans had drawn it to their advantage. A federal court ruled in favor of the congressional map in Pennsylvania, not finding that they were partisan gerrymandering.

Lawmakers suggest that the more "sensible course" is to stay the federal court's decision until the U.S. Supreme Court makes its decision in a separate partisan gerrymandering case out of Wisconsin, Gill v. Whitford. The lawsuit was filed nearly 6 years after the plan became law and after three Congressional elections had been held. That case is the one to watch, said Michael Li, a gerrymandering expert at the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University.

"I wouldn't read too much into this [federal] decision", Li said.

"Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court Judge P. Kevin Brobson's December 2017 recommendation stated: "While Petitioners characterize the level of partisanship evident in the 2011 Plan as "unfair", Petitioners have not articulated a judicially manageable standard by which this Court can discern whether the 2011 Plan crosses the line between permissible partisan considerations and unconstitutional partisan gerrymandering under the Pennsylvania Constitution".

"Although there may be a case in which a political gerrymandering claim may successfully be brought under the Elections Clause, this is not such a case".

A three-judge panel on Wednesday rejected the argument that the map should be thrown out because it gives a political advantage to Republicans. There were statements similar to that made by the legislators in Wisconsin. He renewed his call for plaintiffs to "abandon their costly legal actions and allow the legislature's examination of reforms to move forward". "Spearheaded by the League of Women Voters, this lawsuit is partisan politics under the guise of good public policy", Scarnati said.

"Plaintiffs themselves described being alienated from the political process. In my opinion, gerrymandering will only cause voter turnout to decline even further", Baylson wrote.

The justices heard arguments in the fall over partisan gerrymandering in Wisconsin state legislative districts and could rule in coming months. He proposed his own version, which consists of less-fragmented districts.

Fair Districts PA and other good government groups are sponsoring an informational forum 7-9 p.m. Friday in the Fellowship Hall of First Presbyterian Church of Allentown. It also names Gov. Wolf, members of the General Assembly and other state officials.

Related:

Comments

Latest news

Tully: Trailer and Release Date for Jason Reitman's New Film
Oscar victor Charlize Theron is set to star in upcoming film Tully that explores the realities of motherhood. In the years since then it's been more of a rocky road.

Rio Tinto (LON:RIO) Receives Buy Rating from Jefferies Group
It has outperformed by 27.03% the S&P500. 1/10/2018 - Rio Tinto had its "buy" rating reaffirmed by analysts at Citigroup Inc. The stock was bought at an average cost of GBX 3,490 ($47.33) per share, with a total value of £909,703.40 ($1,233,663.41).

Kris Bryant gets record first-year arbitration deal
Bryant has 94 home runs in his first three seasons in the big leagues to go with a.288 batting average and.388 on-base percentage. He's in the first year of arbitration and has a career 2.94 ERA, 1.098 WHIP and finished third in the NL Cy Young voting in 2016.

Julia Louis-Dreyfus completes chemotherapy
The star shared the news on Twitter , writing , "One in eight women get breast cancer". Julia Louis-Dreyfus has completed a big step in her fight against breast cancer.

Celebrities Who Suffer With Chronic Diseases
Now if that isn’t the epitome of what a BFF is, I don’t know what is! Selena continues to be on chronic medication. There is also a huge list of celebrities past like famous painter vincent Van Gogh who suffered with this disease.

Other news